What "Regulatory Compact"?

I recently came across this quote:

There is ... a long-standing, but unwritten, rule that governs cost recovery and lies at the heart of establishing regulated prices. This rule is known as the regulatory compact. Under the regulatory compact, the regulator grants the company a protected monopoly, essentially a franchise, for the sale and distribution of electricity or natural gas to customers in its defined service territory. In return, the company commits to supply the full quantities demanded by those customers at a price calculated to cover all operating costs plus a "reasonable" return on the capital invested in the enterprise.1

This is the formula fed to regulatory newcomers:  smooth, sweet and easily digested.  But it lacks the essential nutrients. As commonly misused, the phrase "regulatory compact" refers to the regulatory treatment of shareholder investment under the statutory "just and reasonable" standard and the Fifth Amendment's Takings Clause in the U.S. Constitution.2 There is a legal relationship between utility and regulator, and between utility investment and regulator-set rates.  But that legal relationship is not "long-standing," it is not "unwritten," and it is not a "rule."  To call a "compact" what the Supreme Court has described as "essentially ... ad hoc and factual" is artificially narrow, incumbent-protective, and legally wrong.


Artificially Narrow

Those who cite the "regulatory compact" talk only of an exchange of service for money.  The real relationship is richer.  It requires the utility to satisfy the regulator's standards for performance at "lowest feasible cost,"3 to use "all available cost savings opportunities"4; and to pursue its customers' legitimate interests free of conflicting business objectives.  In return, the regulator must establish compensation that is commensurate with the utility's performance.  But there is more.  To set standards for performance and ensure compliance, the regulator must have the resources, expertise and political support that is at least the equal of the utility's.  And for this relationship to work to each party's benefit, it must include a mutual commitment not to use the political process to undermine either the utility's or the regulator's ability to do their jobs.  Those who talk of a "regulatory compact" leave most of these factors out.


Incumbent-Protective

Utilities often cite the "compact" self-referentially, as if it is their compact, created solely to support their specific revenue needs and their specific business success.  (As in, "Utility of the Future" rather than "Customer Needs of the Future.")  But the legal relationship just described transcends any particular utility.  Its foundation is a franchise, of which the incumbent utility is but a temporary grantee, one whose rights depend on performance.  The utility has no lifetime lock on the franchise (see "Regulatory Capture I:  Is It Real?"); nor is it like a New York City taxi medallion—bought from government, resold  for profit.  The franchise is a right to be earned, not demanded.


Legally Wrong

"Regulatory compact" misstates the constitutional relationship between investors and regulators, and between investment and rates.  There is no "compact" for a simple legal fact:  The constitutional protection of shareholder property is far from airtight.  In the landmark case of Duquesne Light Co. v. Barasch, Pennsylvania utilities argued that the Takings Clause (as applied to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause) guarantees full rate recovery of all prudent investment.  The Supreme Court slapped them down: 

We think that the adoption of any such rule would signal a retreat from 45 years of decisional law in this area which would be as unwarranted as it would be unsettling.  Hope clearly held that "the Commission was not bound to the use of any single formula or combination of formulae in determining rates." ... The designation of a single theory of ratemaking as a constitutional requirement would unnecessarily foreclose alternatives which could benefit both consumers and investors.  The Constitution within broad limits leaves the States free to decide what ratesetting methodology best meets their needs in balancing the interests of the utility and the public.5

The case involved a nuclear plant whose construction Duquesne stopped midway.  The Pennsylvania Commission had found that Duquesne's decisions both to begin and to stop constructing were prudent.  But the Commission disallowed recovery of Duquesne's plant costs based on a statute that limited cost recovery to investment that was "used and useful."  The Court rejected the utility's argument that the Constitution required recovery.

This result surprised no non-wishful thinker, because in 1944 the Supreme Court had held that all that matters is the "end result,"6 and in 1945 declared:

The due process clause has been applied to prevent governmental destruction of existing economic values. It has not and cannot be applied to insure values or to restore values that have been lost by the operation of economic forces.7

Given this precedent, those who talk of "the regulatory compact" are putting lipstick on the unpredictable pig of Takings jurisprudence—jurisprudence which, unlike a real compact, is "essentially ... ad hoc and factual."8

These foundational cases—Duquesne, Hope, Jersey Central, Kaiser Aetna and Market Street Railway—do not create a "compact."  They do not create what Lesser and Giacchino call a "long-standing, but unwritten rule that governs cost recovery."  What is "longstanding" is not a "rule" but a principle:  Government must compensate shareholders consistently with the legitimate shareholder expectations government creates.9  In creating those expectations, government is not bound by a "compact"; it is bound by the public interest.  To promote the public interest, regulators set standards for performance, then compensate based on performance.  And regulators can assign risk (including, as in Duquesne, the risk of lousy luck borne by all businesses), then compensate based on the risk thus assigned.

*   *   *

To define the "regulatory compact" as "Government gives us a franchise, we sell service, you pay for service" misses all these points.  The bottom line?  Repetition does not create truth.  There is no "regulatory compact."  As T.S. Eliot wrote:

 

Words strain,

Crack and sometimes, break, under the burden,

Under the tension, slip, slide, perish,

Decay with imprecision, will not stay in place,

Will not stay still. . . .10

 

------------------------------------------------------------

    Lesser and Giacchino, Fundamentals of Energy Regulation (2007) at p.43 (footnote omitted).

2     The Fifth Amendment provides, among other things, that "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation."

3     Potomac Electric Power Co. v. Public Service Commission, 661 A.2d 131, 137 (D.C. 1995).

4     Midwestern Gas Transmission Co. v. East. Tenn. Natural Gas Co., 36 FPC 61, *28 (1966), aff'd sub nom. Midwestern Gas Transmission Co. v. Federal Power Commission, 388 F.2d 444 (7th Cir. 1968).

5     Duquesne Light Co. v. Barasch, 488 U.S. 299, 315-16 (1989) (citations, footnotes omitted) (referring to Hope Natural Gas v. Fed. Power Comm'n, 320 U.S. 591 (1944)).

6     FPC v. Hope Natural Gas Co., 320 U.S. 591 (1944).

7     Market Street Railway Co. v. Railroad Commission of California, 324 U.S. 548, 566 (1945).

8     Jersey Central Power & Light Co. v. FERC, 810 F.2d 1168 (D.C. Cir. 1987) (Starr, J., concurring) (quoting Kaiser Aetna v. United States, 444 U.S. 164, 175 (1979)).  These concepts are discussed in detail in my Regulating Public Utility Performance:  The Law of Market Structure, Pricing and Jurisdiction (American Bar Association 2013) at Chapter 6.

9    Penn Central Transportation Company v. New York, 438 U.S. 104, 124 (1978) (listing factors involved in the Court's Takings analysis, including the "economic impact of the regulation on the claimant and, particularly, the extent to which the regulation has interfered with distinct investment-backed expectations").

10    T.S. Eliot, "Burnt Norton" from Four Quartets (1943).

Comments

Guest

Great web site you have got here.. It's difficult to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I honestly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!! My webpage - Frederick

Guest

Hi, I do believe this is an excellent website. I stumbledupon it ;) I'm going to revisit yet again since I saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others. My blog post :: minecraft

Guest

Great web site you have got here.. It's difficult to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I honesxtly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!! Feel free tto surf too my webpage :: Frederick

Guest

What's up, everything is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that's truly fine, keep up writing. My website :: Ona

Guest

My programmer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using Movable-type on numerous websites for about a year and am nervous about switching to another platform. I have heard fantastic things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated! my blog: minecraft

Guest

Thank you for every other informative blog. The place else may I am getting that kind of information written in such a perfect way? I've a challenge that I am just now operating on, and I have been on the glance out for such info. my weblog - anch

Guest

Excellent post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Many thanks! Here is my homepage; minecraft

Guest

What's up, everything is going nicely here and ocourse every one is sharing data, that's truly fine, keep up writing. Feel free to visit myy blog Ona

Guest

Hi. I have checked your scotthemplinglaw.com and i see you've got some duplicate content so probably it is the reason that you don't rank high in google. But you can fix this issue fast. There is a tool that creates content like human, just search in google: miftolo's tools Also visit my homepage - ChristelBig

Guest

Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it's truly informative. I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! Here is my weblog; minecraft

Guest

Hi. I have checked your scotthemplinglaw.com and i see you've got some duplicate content so probably it is the reason that you don't rank high in google. But you can fix this issue fast. There is a tool that creates content like human, just search in google: miftolo's tools Here is my webpage; ChristelBig

Guest

Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it's truly informative. I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! Also visit my site ... minecraft

Guest

My programmer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using Movable-type on numerous websites for about a year and am nervous about switching to another platform. I have heard fantastic things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated! Feel free to surf to my site minecraft

Guest

Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your post seem to be running off the screen in Opera. I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know. The style and design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Cheers Also visit my blog - minecraft

Guest

You can definitely see your enthusiasm within the work you write. The arena hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. All the time follow your heart. Here is my blog: minecraft

Guest

Excellent post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Many thanks! Feel free to surf to my webpage: minecraft

Guest

Thank you for every other informative blog. The place else may I am getting that kind of information written in such a perfect way? I've a challenge that I am just now operating on, and I have been on the glance out for such info. Check out my webpage; anch

Guest

I do not even know the way I stopped up right here, however I thought this put up was good. I do not recognize who you might be but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you happen to aren't already. Cheers! my site - minecraft; http://tinyurl.com,

Guest

Terrific post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I'd be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it! Take a look at my web page - minecraft

Guest

I do not even know the way I stopped up right here, however I thought this put up was good. I do not recognize who you might be but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you happen to aren't already. Cheers! Feel free to surf to my webpage :: minecraft; http://tinyurl.com,

Guest

Hi, I do believe this is an excellent website. I stumbledupon it ;) I'm going to revisit yet again since I saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others. Feel free to visit my homepage - minecraft

Guest

Thankfulness to my father who stated to me about this webpage, this weblog is genuinely amazing. Also visit my website: minecraft - tinyurl.com,

Guest

Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your post seem to be running off the screen in Opera. I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know. The style and design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Cheers my homepage minecraft

Guest

Terrific post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I'd be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it! my web page minecraft

Guest

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you're a great author. I will make sure to bookmark your blog and will often come back in the future. I want to encourage you continue your great posts, have a nice evening! my webpage :: minecraft

Guest

Thankfulness to my father who stated to me about this webpage, this weblog is genuinely amazing. Here is my blog: minecraft - tinyurl.com,

Guest

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you're a great author. I will make sure to bookmark your blog and will often come back in the future. I want to encourage you continue your great posts, have a nice evening! Also visit my page; minecraft

Guest

You can definitely see your enthusiasm within the work you write. The arena hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. All the time follow your heart. Check out my web-site minecraft

Post new comment