The Dangers of Merger Deference II

When addressing mergers, commission deference makes sense if the transaction's purpose is to improve performance for the customer. But for most mergers, utilities have a different goal.  Last month's essay mentioned four possibilities:  (1) gain a competitive advantage in existing or new markets, (2) strengthen financial condition by diversifying income sources, (3) diversify "regulatory risk" by acquiring utilities in different jurisdictions, and (4) increase access to financial resources by growing company size.  This month I describe three other factors that, if present, argue against deference.

Merger Players Have Diverse Motivations1

1.  Shareholders of the target company seek the highest possible compensation, whether in cash (as in a cash-buyout merger) or in the merged company's stock (as in a stock-for-stock transaction).

2.  Bondholders of the target company want assurance that the rating for their debt does not drop due to lower interest coverages, higher debt-equity ratios, or other factors affecting the merged company's ability to repay.

3. Executives of the target company, if they are remaining on the job post-merger, want certainty about their utility's access to holding company resources and insulation from holding company interference.  Executives expecting to depart post-merger will want "golden parachutes."  For both types of executives, if they own stock in the target company, they will share the goals of the target company shareholders.

4.  Lenders that finance the acquirer's purchase will care about regulatory conditions that affect the income stream necessary to pay off the debt.

5.  In a private equity buyout, general partners expect managerial control free of unnecessary regulation.  Both these general partners and the limited partners (who are passive investors) seek to grow the company's value as quickly as possible so they can take the company public for a profit.

These motivations are not necessarily consistent with a commission's service-improvement goals.

Merger Aspirants Compete for the Target Shareholders' Favor

Merger proponents often argue that they negotiated at arm's length, implying that the terms were disciplined by competitive forces. The adversarial relations inherent in such negotiations, they say, ensure the merger's consistency with the public interest.  This argument makes the common error of importing competitive market theory into a monopoly market context.

It is true that a merger transaction is subject to competition.  But it is a competition won by offering the target company's shareholders the highest price, not by offering customers the best possible service.  That is where the conflict arises, where the public interest suffers.  The higher the acquisition price, the higher the acquirer's debt; the higher the acquirer's debt, the greater its need to raise rates, cut service quality or delay rate decreases.  In true competition, the interests of the company and the customer are aligned; in a merger transaction, they are in conflict.

This conflict, between acquisition strategy and customer benefit, exists if the ultimate retail customers are captive customers.  An acquirer of a bakery might offer premiums to target shareholders, but the offer is disciplined by the competitive market for baked goods.  If the post-acquisition merged company raises its prices to recover the acquisition cost, its customers will buy their donuts elsewhere—or eat oatmeal at home.

That is why commissions must lead, not defer.  The target utility has a fiduciary obligation to get the greatest gain for its shareholders.  (I know of no utility that seeks merger proposals that put customer benefits first.)  If the commission sets no acquisition price, quality standards or post-merger rate levels, the fiduciary obligation will trump the consumer interest.  Commission deference removes the arm's-length distance.  Negotiations are arm's length when each party risks financial loss.  In a merger of monopolies whose regulators defer to the deal, there is no risk of financial loss.  The bargaining is not arm's length.

Further, without arm's-length bargaining—without hosting a competition for the customer's favor—the regulator cannot evaluate the merger objectively.  Merger proponents often compare their transaction to the status quo, arguing that there is no harm and some benefit.  But regulation's purpose is not to avoid harm and produce some benefit.  Regulation's purpose is to produce the most cost-effective performance.  Because a merger transaction necessarily precludes some other transaction, because $300 million spent on an acquisition premium is $300 million not spent on energy efficiency or other improvements, because the target company will choose the coupling that pays its shareholders the most, rather than the one that benefits its customers the most, deference deprives customers of what real competition can do:  force a comparison that ranks the options and reveals the optimal.  That is the purpose of regulation.

The Host Utility Has a Conflict of Interest

The target company's hope for the highest possible premium creates a conflict of interest—a conflict no less severe than if a commissioner held stock in the target company while voting for the merger.  The consumer interest might not be ignored, but it is compromised. 

When the utility's conflict of interest is combined with its superior knowledge, the danger of deference looms larger.  Consider the temporary rate freeze typically offered by applicants.  The beneficiary can be customers or shareholders, depending on the facts.  If absent the merger the utility's costs would have risen, the freeze is a customer benefit.  But if costs would have been stable or declining, the freeze keeps rates above costs (assuming the merger reduces costs).  Without a full cost-of-service inquiry, the commission will not know which set of facts applies—but the utility does know.  Conflict of interest plus control of information argues against deference. The solution is to eliminate the information asymmetry, by requiring merger applications to include full rate case information, and by conditioning any merger approval on new rates reflecting that information.  This treatment makes explicit the merger's financial consequences for all parties. 

*    *    *

Merger deference ignores merger realities.  Absent competition or regulation, owner and customer interests diverge.  Full competition causes those interests to converge:  Companies design their mergers to satisfy the customer.  In a monopoly market, they design their mergers to satisfy the regulators.  If regulators defer, the interests will diverge, with customer interest subordinate.  Next month's essay will describe those merger policies that, like competition cause the interests to converge.

----------------------------------

1 I am indebted to Stephen G. Hill for this list.  See his superb paper, “Private Equity Buyouts of Public Utilities: Preparation for Regulators” (National Regulatory Research Institute 2007).

Comments

Guest

Appreciating the hard work you put into your blog and detailed information you provide. It's good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't the same old rehashed information. Wonderful read! I've bookmarked your site and I'm including your RSS feeds to my Google account. Check out my web site ... Zapatillas Golden Goose Francy Mujer

Guest

Appreciating the hard work you put into your blog and detailed information you provide. It's good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't the same old rehashed information. Wonderful read! I've bookmarked your site and I'm including your RSS feeds to my Google account. Also visit my web site; Zapatillas Golden Goose Francy Mujer

Guest

Thanks for finally writing about > The Dangers of Merger Deference II | Scott Hempling < Loved it! Also visit my web page; Golden Goose Super Star Soldes

Guest

Ahaa, its pleasant discussion about this post here at this webpage, I have read all that, so now me also commenting at this place. Feel free to visit my webpage Golden Goose 2.12 Outlet

Guest

Hi, I desire to subscribe for this blog to get hottest updates, so where can i do it please help out. Also visit my blog post ... Botas Isabel Marant Outlet Barcelona

Guest

No matter if some one searches for his required thing, so he/she desires to be available that in detail, therefore that thing is maintained over here. my page Sandalias Isabel Marant Baratas

Guest

Thanks for finally writing about > The Dangers of Merger Deference II | Scott Hempling < Loved it! My homepage Golden Goose Super Star Soldes

Guest

Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is fantastic, as well as the content! Feel free to surf to my blog post :: Isabel Marant España

Guest

Wow, incredible blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is fantastic, as well as the content! Here is my site ... Isabel Marant España

Guest

Hi, I desire to subscribe for this blog to get hottest updates, so where can i do it please help out. Here is my blog Botas Isabel Marant Outlet Barcelona

Guest

No matter if some one searches for his required thing, so he/she desires to be available that in detail, therefore that thing is maintained over here. my web blog - Sandalias Isabel Marant Baratas

Guest

Ahaa, its pleasant discussion about this post here at this webpage, I have read all that, so now me also commenting at this place. Also visit my web page :: Golden Goose 2.12 Outlet

Guest

Lonergan said Affleck had given "one of the most brilliant performances I've ever seen - or think I will" in a film about looking grief and sorrow in the face.Yu also urged better communications and cooperation on culture and trade with Taiwan on the basis of the "1992 Consensus," while enhancing unity and ties with overseas patriots and the younger generation. Davies’ revival of Doctor Who in 2005, American audiences have had to wait with anticipation for the new adventures of the Doctor to reach the states, as episodes were already airing in the UK. Cheap NFL Jerseys Wholesale. What does it take to get into (Whatever automobile you€re trying to find)?four.Cheap Nike NFL Jerseys Wholesale.S. Brazil In 1958,Cheap Jerseys Wholesale, Brazil won its very first World Cup title and in doing so, established themselves as a powerhouse to be reckoned with for generations to come. Using a downline builder is free and a great way to start your List building, one of the best reasons to have your own downline is to give free products and services to your downline and to offer onetime sales or have many repeat sales from different customers on your list. These sites can be your local law enforcement stations, sheriff offices among others.More to You: Frequent nightfall for a long duration can invite numbers of health crises. The High Museum of Art has beautiful things to see, designed primarily by the architect Renzo Piano. Tax season is approaching and absolutely everyone will get something back from our stunning government provide is and get the vehicle you desire and ought to have!!!Georgia Car SalesRJ shows passion in car dealership and has been publishing articles that will help you decide in getting your car.com know and trust.Visit my sitehttp://www.cheapnflchinajerseyswholesale.us.com/

Guest

Il immediately postwholesale nfl jerseys take hold of your rss as I can not find your email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please permit me recognise so that I may just subscribe. Thanks. cheap jerseys free http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

relationships with other bloggers. Check out this extremely well-written trackback tutorial Permalink,we supply cheap nfl jerseys. where can i buy cheap jerseys online http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

Discover what's the deal with ingbacks? According to Wikipedia, WP supports automatic pingbacks where all the links in a published article can be pinged when the article is published?we supply cheap nfl jerseys That explains why I get messages about new comments? when posting an edit that cross-references another post of my own. Info on trackbacks and pingbacks in WP here. affordable nfl gear http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all of us you really recognise what you're speaking about! Bookmarked.postwholesale nfl jerseys, Kindly additionally consult with my web site =). We will have a link trade contract between us! game jerseys wholesale http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

I do agree with all the ideas you've presented in your postcheap nfl jerseys china. They are very convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are too short for beginners. Could you please extend them a bit from next time? Thanks for the post. american football jerseys cheap http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all folks you really understand what you're speaking about! Bookmarked.postcheap nike nfl jerseys, Please additionally visit my web site =). We may have a hyperlink exchange contract between us! new cheap nfl jerseys http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

I been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area post. Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Reading this information So i am happy to convey that I've a very good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to do not forget this site and give it a glance regularly. discount nfl jerseys online http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

In the WordPress support forum, there are from time to time questions abut trackbacks. I haven't used it myself, but I found a good tutorial on the OptiNiche cheap nfl jerseys china blog. cheap football jerseys from china http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your weblog and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account we supply cheap nfl jerseys your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently quickly. good cheap jerseys http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

Discover what's the deal with ingbacks? According to Wikipedia, WP supports automatic pingbacks where all the links in a published article can be pinged when the article is published?we supply cheap nfl jerseys That explains why I get messages about new comments? when posting an edit that cross-references another post of my own. Info on trackbacks and pingbacks in WP here. best cheap jersey site http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in truth was a entertainment account it. Glance complex to far brought agreeable from you! However, how can we keep up a correspondence? wholesale for jerseys http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

I'm really impressed with your writing skills postcheap nike nfl jerseys as well as with the layout on your blog with cheap nfl jerseys. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself? Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one these days where can i buy cheap jerseys online http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you actually recognize what you're talking about! Bookmarked.postcheap jerseys, Please additionally visit my site =). We will have a hyperlink exchange contract between us! Wholesale 2019 Super Bowl NFL Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Guest

Thank you for the good writeup. It in reality was a enjoyment account it. Look complicated to far delivered agreeable from you! By the way, how could we keep in touch? 2019 Super Bowl NFL Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Guest

Hello there, just became aware of your blog via Google, and found that it's really informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate in case you continue this in future. Lots of other people will be benefited out of your writing. Cheers! Wholesale 2019 Super Bowl NFL Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Guest

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, postcheap nike nfl jerseysand found that it's truly informative cheap nfl jerseys. I gonna watch out for brussels. Il appreciate if you continue this in future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! 2019 Super Bowl Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Guest

Hello there, just changed into alert to your blog thru Google, and located that it is truly informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. Il appreciate if you proceed this in future. Lots of other people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! Cheap Super Bowl NFL Jersey From China http://www.2019cheapnfl.com/2019superbowljersey-ezp-18.html

Guest

We're a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your website offered us with valuable info to work on cheap nfl jerseys china. You have done an impressive job and our whole community will be grateful to you. 2019 Super Bowl Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Guest

ENJOY WATCHING!It appears that Doctor Who fans in America will no longer have to wait months to catch up to the BBC’s UK broadcasts, as the premiere date for Doctor Who season 6 is set for April 23, in both the US and UK. So it is very important that you build a relationship with your subscribers. If you are using article marketing then offer a free report to download. It€s seriously that straightforward! My Boss always says this is not a museum we move vehicles enormous amounts of vehicles and if you€re selling as numerous cars as we are your trying to find causes to sell you the auto not reasons not to sell you a vehicle.S. It is actually an ADVENTURE!!Fantastic Concerns to ask:1. Last year’s Doctor Who Christmas Special attracted 727,000 viewers in total, up from 671,000 viewers that tuned into the 2009 Christmas Special. Just take a glimpse on his blogs and learn all the process in having one. 12 (Xinhua) -- La La Land a film telling the story of an aspiring actress and a dedicated jazz musician struggling to make ends meet while pursuing their dreams won Britain's top movie prize Sunday. In fact, Wholesale NFL Jerseys China,Wholesale Jerseys China Cheap, without the right charger, you wouldn’t even be able to turn your phone on.The prize for the outstanding British film went to the movie I Daniel Blake a story that documents life in the welfare state of 21st century Britain.Cheap Jerseys USA.The airline also announced the delivery of a substitute aircraft to continue the flight service, saying that "safety and comfort of our customers is our first priority and we flew a substitute aircraft to continue with the flight service for our valued customers.Visit my sitehttp://www.cheapnfljerseyschinashop.com/

Guest

Somebody necessarily assist to make critically articles I'd state. postwholesale nfl jerseysThat is the very first time I frequented your website page and to this point? I surprised with the analysis you made to create this actual publish extraordinary. Wonderful job! cheap nfl shirts http://www.pasbesoinde.org/newpage2.html

Guest

I am extremely impressed with your writing skills postcheap nike nfl jerseys and also with the layout on your weblog with cheap nfl jerseys. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself? Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one these days nfl jerseys for sale online http://www.speleo.qc.ca/page10.html

Guest

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your site offered us with valuable info to work on cheap nfl jerseys china. You have done a formidable job and our whole community will be grateful to you. redskins jersey cheap http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

relationships with other bloggers. Check out this extremely well-written trackback tutorial Permalink,we supply cheap nfl jerseys. super cheap jerseys http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

I been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area postcheap nike nfl jerseys. Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Reading this information So i happy to convey that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to don't forget this web site and give it a glance regularly. cheap nfl clothing http://www.araq.net/wholesalejerseys.asp

Guest

Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your weblog and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account we supply cheap nfl jerseys your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently quickly. cheap jersey nfl best http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy to cheap nfl jerseys china. The overall look of your website is great, postas well as the content! online jersey wholesale http://legacy.deeroaks.com/

Guest

I been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area postcheap nfl jerseys. Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Reading this info So i happy to convey that I've an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to do not forget this site and give it a glance on a constant basis. real nfl jerseys http://www.karatequebec.com/pic/cheapnfljerseys.asp

Guest

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that cheap nfl jerseys china I have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!postwholesale nfl jerseys. 2019 Super Bowl NFL Jersey http://www.2019cheapnfl.com/2019superbowljersey-ezp-18.html

Guest

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, postwholesale nfl jerseysand found that it's truly informative cheap nfl jerseys. I gonna watch out for brussels. Il be grateful if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers! Super Bowl Jersey http://www.2019cheapnfl.com/2019superbowljersey-ezp-18.html

Guest

relationships with other bloggers. Check out this extremely well-written trackback tutorial Permalink,we supply cheap nfl jerseys. Cheap Super Bowl NFL Jersey http://www.kpsearch.com/2019superbowl.html

Post new comment